Amanda Palmer: Who Killed Amanda Palmer?

Amanda Palmer of The Dresden Dolls will release her debut solo effort Who Killed Amanda Palmer? (title inspired by Twin Peaks) on September 16th. Palmer’s original concept was of a simple piano and voice collection recorded in her bedroom within one week, but the arrival of producer Ben Folds brought the recording to a proper studio and transformed it into a slicker project embellished with string and orchestral arrangements. Folds contributes backing vocals, keyboards, and percussion to the album, while Rasputina’s Zoë Keating provides cello. Members of The Dead Kennedys and St. Vincent also make cameos. The album apparently contains liner notes written by graphic novelist Neil Gaiman, but the advance disc I received did not have any of the artwork.


Still I always shock them when I answer
“Hi, my name’s Amanda”
I’m not going to live my life on one side of an ampersand
Even if I went with you, I’m not the girl you think I am

Amanda names the opener as her “hands-down favorite” song on the album as well as the track that most represents her current songwriting style. “Astronaut” is initially driven by the thunderous force of Palmer’s piano before her somber alto slides in for the quiet opening verse. Then the chorus explodes into a soaring pop melody plumped up with whirring strings and clanging cymbals.

The hyperactive, atmospheric “Runs in the Family” is my personal favorite on the album. It’s an older song that I believe Amanda wrote during the “Girl Anachronism”/”Half Jack” era, and it definitely sounds more like a Dresden Dolls piece than the rest. The Dolls association may be why Palmer hesitated to put the song on the album, but fortunately Ben Folds convinced her to include it.

It sounds like Folds whispering “manda” at the beginning of “Ampersand”, but I can’t say for certain. The ballad features some lovely piano work, and perhaps Palmer’s most heartfelt vocal performance. To be honest, I didn’t like it much the first time I heard it. Amanda’s deep voice is not the easiest fit for so soft a song. But the second time around, something in the song – the intimate lyrics I suppose, maybe the surprising vulnerability in her voice – clicked with me and it’s since become another favorite.

“Leeds United” is the first single from the new disc, a slinky punk stunner built around a marching band chorus and Palmer’s spatial raspings. The tune was recorded spontaneously during the Edinburgh Fringe Festival with a group of local Scottish horn players. The chilling “Strength Through Music” is a sparse piano ballad originally inspired by and written during the aftermath of Columbine, but Amanda did not record the song until those memories were reawakened by the recent Virginia Tech shootings.

The quiet is quickly ripped back open by the swaggering “Guitar Hero” (featuring guest East Bay Ray of The Dead Kennedys), a cynical ode to the video game and its addicts in which Palmer finally lets her wail go. St. Vincent‘s Annie Clark lends her operatic soprano to the tinkling duet of Carousel’s “What’s The Use of Wondrin”.

The advance disc I received lists “Oasis” as track ten, but it’s been called “Melissa Mahoney” elsewhere. I think the latter title is the true one, though both phrases are in the song’s lyrics. Either way, Palmer refers to it as “a pop song about abortion”. “The Point of it All” is a heartier ballad that accentuates the more elegant tone of Amanda’s voice, while the pretty piano melody “Another Year” serves as the album’s wistful finale.

Amanda Palmer – Runs in the Family (mp3) (removed at label’s request after permission granted by artist’s manager…the trials of legal blogging)

Amanda Palmer MySpace
The Dresden Dolls Official Site

Buy @ Amazon

7 thoughts on “Amanda Palmer: Who Killed Amanda Palmer?

  1. I think it’s spelled Neil Gaiman.
    Very nice review of what’s likely the album of the year for me.

    Anna

  2. Anna – thanks for catching my typo! And for the compliment on my review. 🙂 I had some big expectations for this album and I can’t say I love it as much as The Dresden Dolls debut (but then, that’s probably my fave CD ever), but it’s definitely one of my favorites of the year so far and I like it more with each listen.

  3. I’m so excited for this album! I keep waiting for the pre-order to go up. Just to clear up some confusion, Neil Gaiman is not doing the linear notes. He is actually writing a book with Amanda. She explained it at a concert recently, saying that records labels had been going under (many people cheered when she said that). She replied that it might be nice for them, but it was hard for artists when they wanted to put out beautiful book booklets with their albums, and the label couldn’t afford it. So she decided to make a book instead, and she needed someone famous to work on it with her so that people would be interested. She asked Neil, and he said yes. He came to stay at her house/apartment for a week and they worked on it together.

    I’m so excited to see the book! The stories he wrote for Tori’s Strange Little Girls were fabulous.

    XOXO
    ~Malinda

  4. Pingback: Amanda Palmer: Leeds United Video « Muruch

  5. Pingback: Amanda Palmer: Strength Through Music Video « Muruch

  6. Pingback: The Dresden Dolls: DVD Contest « Muruch

  7. Pingback: Women (in Music): Second Class Citizens? « Muruch

Comments are closed.